Back to Menu Page
A Tale of Two Trees
One happy day in May the all-American dream came true for two families. Brand new houses of their own in the suburbs. The good life for their kids. New friends and neighbors. More space and comfort. And good investments, too. Now, it happened that both families loved trees, so they each promptly planted one to commemorate their new start in life. Unknown to each other,
Page 1 - How to Prune Young Shade Trees Page 2 - Tale of Two TreesPage 3 - A Tale of Two Trees - con'tPage 4 - Pruning for Strength Page 5 - Pruning for Form Page 6 - Keys To Good Pruning - When To PrunePage 7 - Pruning Is A Vital Part Of Any Urban Forestry ProgramPage 8 - Other Sources of Information
both families planted trees that were the same species and the same age. Looking ahead, we would expect the twin trees to eventually make a nice contribution to the neighborhood, each spreading its shade to grateful residents for generations to come. But, it was not to be. Unfortunately, Family A had the misguided belief that a tree should be left alone, just as it is in ... (continued on Page 3 - A Tale of Two Trees - con't) ...
BackNext

At Planting
   Family A didn't ask for planting instructions They knew how to plant a tree. When that was done, they believed their work was done. Actually. they were partlv correct. You may receive instructions to the contrary, but little should be done to the tree at this stage. In most cases, it is best to leave all the leaf surface possible to manufacture food that will build a larger root system. It has been found that both roots and top will be larger after one year if left unpruned.

After 5-7 Years
   The baby is quickly becoming an adult. The results of not making corrections early in life are now quite visible, although some are still not obvious to the untrained eye. To the more careful observer, the form of the future crown is apparent.
After 3-4 Years
   By the time many transplants are in their new home for 2 to 4 growing seasons, sprouts and suckers may appear. The root suckers protruding near the base sap strength from the tree. The sprouts are disproportionally vigorous and weakly attached to the tree. And look at the broken limb. By now, it has sprouted numerous branches just below the break too many, in fact.
FAMILY A's TREE -- Not Pruned When Young
15 Years After Planting
   Family A's tree is now not only unattractive, but dangerous, especially when the wind is blowing. Lopsided and dense, the tree in full leaf catches the wind like a sail. Also, the narrow branch angles and multiple leaders have resulted in a weak top. The broken branch not only attracted insects, but may soon break off under the weight of too many sprouts. Decay has entered the trunk where the little bent branch tore off many years ago and a jagged stub protrudes just above it. The tree is an accident waiting to happen. It is becoming more of a liability than an asset for the property.